|
by Xinhua Writers Qu Junya, Ling Shuo
BEIJING, July 1 (Xinhua) -- The United Nations Convention on the law of Sea (UNCLOS) has not resolved every past global dispute and neither will it for the South China Sea arbitration the Philippines has unilaterally initiated in The Hague.
China has elaborated on the reasons why in a position paper released in Dec. 2014. For one, the arbitration involves issues of territorial sovereignty over which UNCLOS has no jurisdiction. Hence China's non-acceptance of and non-participation in the arbitration is justified.
China supports international law and that is why it rejects the Manila initiative. This stand is taken to ensure that international law is safe from political abuse and manipulation.
However, China's stance has been labeled as being in contempt to and non-compliance with international law by some Western governments and media.
In fact, respect for international law should not mean being forced to accept an arbitration that goes beyond UNCLOS' scope.
Any arbitration ruling is unlikely to hold. This is partly because no international dispute concerning national sovereignty has so far been settled by a single arbitration based on international law, with the decades-long Palestinian-Israeli conflict as an example.
But international law is limited too. For disputes where multilateral interests instead of territorial claims are concerned, international law has hardly worked. So often, mechanisms under international conventions or pacts alleviate humanitarian crises but without eliminating their roots, as we see with the recent refugee influx into Europe.
Prof. Jack Goldsmith of Harvard University and Prof. Eric Posner of Chicago University write in the book, Limits of International Law, that international law is based on and restricted by national interests.
The South China Sea issue is an exact showcase of their opinion.
The issue is a complex one with political and historical factors to address. Negotiating a peaceful solution is the way forward in consideration of history, diplomacy, culture, energy, security and transportation.
To this end, an effective mechanism is necessary for consultation, and the Declaration on the Conduct of Parties in the South China Sea approved in 2002 by China and all members of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations needs to be reinforced.
China is not opposed to rules but safeguards them and calls for rules that are rational. However, rules to solve the South China Sea issue should not be set thousands of miles away by oceanographers or legal experts of a five-member arbitral tribunal mainly from on the basis of geological structure or the natural quality of reefs. Neither should any conclusion on any complex regional issue be drawn one-sidedly.
UNCLOS needs the protection of every member to keep it from being reduced to a geopolitical tool, and its reasonable use relies on cooperative diplomatic and political efforts. The work of the tribunal in The Hague on this front has been a huge disservice.
Related:
China reaffirms non-acceptance of South China Sea arbitration
BEIJING, June 30 (Xinhua) -- China reaffirmed on Thursday that it will not accept a third party dispute settlement or any solution imposed on China.
Foreign Ministry spokesperson Hong Lei made the remarks at a routine press briefing when asked to comment on the Arbitral Tribunal's claim that it would soon issue the so-called final award of the South China Sea arbitration unilaterally initiated by the Philippines. Full story
Consultation is way to keep peace, stability in South China Sea: Greek party official
ATHENS, June 30 (Xinhua) -- Amicable consultation is the only way to resolve the escalating tension in the South China Sea, a Greek party official and expert in international relations told Xinhua on Wednesday.
Vassiliki Souladaki, deputy secretary of international relations department of the socialist PASOK party and an expert in foreign policy affairs, urged for honest dialogue between sovereign states on the basis of respecting historical facts and in accordance with international law, to put an end to the dispute. Full story
Commentary: Manic South China Sea arbitration melting foundation of int'l order
BEIJING, June 30 (Xinhua) -- China is defending not only its territorial sovereignty but world peace and stability when fighting against the obstinacy displayed in the South China Sea arbitration.
The Arbitral Tribunal in the South China Sea arbitration, established at the unilateral request of the Republic of the Philippines, claimed on Wednesday that it would issue the final "award" on July 12. Full story
Spotlight: Int'l experts criticize Hague arbitration tribunal over South China Sea
BEIJING, June 30 (Xinhua) -- International experts criticized an arbitral tribunal with widely contested jurisdiction for its plan to issue an award on July 12 on the South China Sea case unilaterally initiated by the Philippines.
The government of outgoing Philippine President Benigno Aquino III filed the arbitration against China in 2013, despite the agreement his country had reached with China on resolving their South China Sea disputes through bilateral negotiations. Full story
Commentary: Ill-grounded S. China Sea arbitration to only worsen disputes among neighbors
BEIJING, June 29 (Xinhua) -- The South China Sea arbitration unilaterally initiated by the Philippines does not hold water from a legal standpoint and will not put an end to the South China Sea disputes, but only worsen them. Full story
Law-abusing tribunal to issue award on South China Sea arbitration
THE HAGUE, June 29 (Xinhua) -- An arbitral tribunal with widely contested jurisdiction will issue an award on July 12 on the South China Sea case unilaterally initiated by the Philippines, the Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA) in The Hague said on Wednesday. Full story
Backgrounder: Timeline of Philippines' unilaterally initiated South China Sea arbitration case
BEIJING, June 29 (Xinhua) -- The Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA) in The Hague has said on Wednesday that an arbitral tribunal with widely contested jurisdiction will issue an award on July 12 on the South China Sea case unilaterally initiated by the Philippines. Full story
